top of page

Top Smart Thermostats: Brains vs. Beauty vs. Budget

Modern smart thermostat displaying temperature with surrounding eco-friendly and connectivity icons, representing energy-efficient home automation.

In today’s world, the advancement in smart home technology has completely transformed our way of living by offering convenience, control, and most importantly energy efficiency. One crucial component of a home is the smart thermostat. Unlike old-school thermostats, these innovative devices go above and beyond to optimize energy usage, reduce costs, and provide seamless control. In this blog post, we will delve into the advantages of utilizing smart thermostats, dispel common misconceptions associated with them, and compare various popular brands/models to assist you in making an informed decision for your home.


Energy Efficiency

The objective of smart thermostats is to optimize your energy consumption. By learning your heating and cooling preferences over time, these intelligent devices automatically adjust temperature settings to ensure comfort when you're at home while conserving energy efficiently when you're away. As a result of this approach, significant energy savings can be achieved compared to using traditional thermostats.


Cost Savings

The reduction in energy consumption not only benefits the environment but also has a positive impact on your finances. Smart thermostats offer long-term cost savings by minimizing wasted energy and ultimately reducing your utility bills. Moreover, it's worth mentioning that many utility companies provide rebates or incentives for installing energy devices such as smart thermostats. This factor further enhances the potential for greater savings and return on investment.


Control Made Convenient

With the help of thermostats, managing the temperature of your home has become incredibly simple. All it takes is a tap on your smartphone or a voice command to your assistant. You can even control it from afar ensuring an atmosphere when you arrive. By integrating with smartphone apps and popular voice assistants like Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant, you have effortless control.


Integration with Smart Home Systems

Smart thermostats are not just devices; they seamlessly connect with other smart home systems to form a complete ecosystem. By syncing up with devices such as lighting, motorized shades, or occupancy sensors, your home can automatically adapt its temperature settings based on factors like natural light or whether rooms are occupied. This level of automation optimizes energy usage enhances comfort levels and simplifies your routines.


Comparing Different Smart Thermostat Brands

There are reputable brands that offer smart thermostats with different features and functionalities. Let's take a look at some options.


The image shows a modern programmable thermostat. The main unit is black with a curved, rectangular shape and a large, central digital screen displaying the temperature at 72 degrees. On the screen, various icons suggest other functionalities such as weather conditions, presumably humidity levels, and air quality or cleaning settings. There's also a smaller, circular device in white, possibly a remote sensor, standing on a small metallic base to the left of the main thermostat unit. The brand "ecobee" is visible at the bottom of the thermostat's display, indicating the manufacturer.

The Ecobee SmartThermostat comes with built-in room sensors, which monitor the temperature in parts of your home ensuring that every room is comfortable. The sensors also recognize motion, so they know which rooms are occupied and can adjust temperatures accordingly. Additionally, the device can seamlessly connect with voice assistants for convenient control. Some ecobee's also come with Amazon Alexa embedded.


Many professional installers prefer Ecobees for their premium capabilities. Our WattSherpa family was originally a Nest household. We reluctantly switched to Ecobees under the guidance of our geothermal energy installer, and we have been pleasantly surprised. The Nest is still prettier, but Ecobee's learning capabilities and automated eco+ functionality have been a step above the Nest in our experience. The eco+ mode unlocks additional energy savings by making recommendations and adjusting for i) your household’s schedule and indoor humidity, ii) real-time energy demand in your community, and iii) peak/off-peak electricity pricing where possible. And the interface just feels more intuitive, other than that smooth turn of the Nest dial that we do miss.


The image is of a round, wall-mounted smart thermostat with a high-resolution display. The interface shows a bright orange background, indicating that the heating is on, with the temperature set to 68 degrees Fahrenheit. A small leaf icon, often associated with energy-saving modes or eco-friendly settings, is visible on the display. The perimeter of the device has a metallic finish with a textured edge, suggesting a dial function for temperature adjustment. This design is characteristic of the Nest Learning Thermostat, particularly noted for its minimalist aesthetic and user-friendly interface.

If you're focused on form over function, you have to go for the Nest. Since its launch, Nest has been one of the most beautiful smart home devices in the market. Ecobee doesn't hold a candle to the design and tactile experience of the Nest, with its perfectly tuned scroll wheel.


Like the ecobee, Nest continuously learns your temperature preferences and makes adjustments accordingly. However, in our experience, the automation just never worked quite as well as the Ecobee does for us now. Nonetheless, it provides excellent remote control capabilities, scheduling, energy reports, etc. And it is certainly the winner in terms of aesthetics.


Nest also offers a less expensive model, the Nest Thermostat, which has a more minimalist design and lacks the "Learning" part. It's not as beautiful but is still a sleek option at a much better price.


Best Budget Option - Amazon Smart Thermostat

The image features a square-shaped smart thermostat with rounded corners and a minimalist white design. The digital display shows the temperature reading as 68 degrees, indicated by large, bold, white numbers that appear to float on the device's surface. There is a small, circular sensor or button centrally located below the temperature readout, and two faint dots that may be part of the interface or sensors. The overall design is sleek and modern, with an emphasis on simplicity and functionality.

If you're open to super minimalist design, it doesn't get any more simple than the Amazon Smart Thermostat. However, anyone can love the price point, which is usually significantly cheaper than a Nest or Ecobee. You can click on any of the thermostat images or links above to see the latest prices on Amazon. This model is consistently reviewed as the best budget option in the smart thermostat category.


The device is designed to seamlessly integrate into Amazon's ecosystem, allowing for easy voice control and streamlined automation. However, it ironically does not come with Alexa or a speaker built-in, which is something that does come with an Ecobee.


This thermostat also requires a common, or "C" wire, to function, so you may have to pay a little extra for an adapter if you don't have an existing C wire in your electrical system. Even if you have to pay for an adapter, you're still paying much less for this device than its luxurious peers.


Misconceptions About Smart Thermostats

Contrary to what many believe, installing a smart thermostat is often straightforward and user-friendly. Detailed instructions are usually included with the device. If you need further guidance, online tutorials are readily available.


Some people may question the energy savings achieved by using smart thermostats. However, studies have shown that these devices can significantly reduce energy consumption, leading to savings on heating and cooling costs.


Smart thermostats offer more advanced features and connectivity options than their traditional counterparts. With remote control capabilities, automation options, and integration possibilities, smart thermostats are a great choice for homeowners who prioritize energy efficiency.


Make sure that your smart thermostat is compatible with the smart home devices you have. This compatibility allows for integration and a seamless smart home experience.


Conclusion for Smart Thermostats Review

Smart thermostats are more than convenient gadgets. They provide benefits such as energy efficiency, cost savings, and improved control. By utilizing these devices, you can create a greener and more comfortable home while reducing your environmental impact.


Embrace the future of home climate control by considering the integration of a smart thermostat into your home’s HVAC system. Take the step towards an energy-efficient and cost-effective home by exploring the wide range of options available in the market. Your wallet and the planet will appreciate it!


Go with an Ecobee if you want the best function, a Nest for the best design, or an Amazon Smart Thermostat for the best price.


Comments


bottom of page